What Stoicism Is Not: 7 Myths That Keep People Away
Daily Stoic Wisdom
Published
"Isn't that the one where you don't feel anything?"
You mention at dinner that you've been reading Marcus Aurelius. Your friend laughs. "So you're going to stop having feelings now?" Someone else has seen a video about it, the one with gym music and a marble bust in the thumbnail.
Nobody at the table is being unkind. They just know the word, and the word has picked up a lot along the way. Most people decide what Stoicism is long before they read a page of it, and some of what they decide is the reason they never do.
Here are seven of those ideas, and what the old texts say instead. A couple of them have a grain of truth, and we'll get to that too.
Myth 1: Stoic means feeling nothing
Lowercase "stoic" in English means enduring pain without showing it. The everyday word comes from the philosophy, but the two have drifted a long way apart.
The ancient Stoics did want to be free of what they called passions, but they meant something narrower than emotion: feelings that run on bad judgments, like panic over a remark that wasn't meant as an insult, or rage at a delayed train as if it had been late on purpose. Epictetus is blunt about the rest. He says he ought not to be without feeling "like a statue", but should keep up his relationships as a son, a father and a citizen (Discourses 3.2, Long's translation).
So grief at a funeral is no Stoic failure, and neither is the jolt when a car pulls out in front of you. What they tried to train was the judgment that comes a second later, when you decide the driver did it to you on purpose.
Myth 2: It's about accepting everything and doing nothing
This one comes from the most famous Stoic idea, that some things are up to you and some aren't. Read quickly, it sounds like permission to shrug. Your landlord won't fix the heating? Not up to you. Move on.
Epictetus used it the other way round. The line tells you where to aim your effort: at the part you can actually move, like the email to the landlord and the complaint to the housing office. Then you stop torturing yourself over the reply. Most real problems are partly yours, and the dichotomy of control guide works through exactly that objection, so I won't repeat it here.
It's also worth remembering who wrote this stuff. Marcus Aurelius ran an empire, and Seneca spent years advising Nero.
Myth 3: It's a toughness contest
Some corners of the internet have turned Stoicism into a way of never needing anyone. Wake at five, never complain, and treat asking for help as weakness.
Marcus wrote the opposite to himself. "Be not ashamed to be helped; for it is thy business to do thy duty like a soldier in the assault on a town" (Meditations 7.7, Long's translation). He goes on to picture a lame soldier who can't climb the wall alone. With help he can, so he should take it.
The image is military, which may be part of the appeal to the gym crowd. The point he draws from it is that getting the job done matters more than your pride about doing it alone. Calling a friend when your week has fallen apart fits that fine. So does seeing a therapist.
Myth 4: Stoics are cold toward other people
Closely related, and probably the myth that puts off the most people. If you're working so hard on your own judgments, the reasoning goes, you must care less about everyone else.
Marcus, writing early in Book 2 about the irritating people he expects to meet that day, says: "For we are made for co-operation, like feet, like hands, like eyelids, like the rows of the upper and lower teeth" (Meditations 2.1, Long's translation). He's annoyed with them and still treats them as part of the same body.
There's a whole older post on this, Stoicism and Empathy, which goes into it properly.
Myth 5: It's a philosophy for rich men
It's easy to see where this comes from. Seneca was very wealthy, and his critics in Rome said so. Marcus was an emperor. The modern revival has been marketed heavily to founders and executives.
But one of the three best-known Stoics was born into slavery. Epictetus taught that the part of you that matters can't be owned by anyone, and he'd had every reason to think hard about that (his story is here). His own teacher, Musonius Rufus, gave a lecture arguing that women should study philosophy too, since they have the same capacity for reason as men. That was not a common view in first-century Rome.
You don't need money or any Greek to start. George Long's translations, the ones quoted on this page, are old enough to be free online.
Myth 6: It's a productivity system
Search for Stoicism now and you'll find plenty of "hacks" and morning routines promising more output. Some of those habits are fine. The Stoics were after something else, though: becoming good people. They thought a good character was the only thing that reliably made a life go well.
That changes what counts as a bad day. For a Stoic, missing your targets barely registers next to being unfair to a colleague, or lying to get out of something awkward. A productivity app won't flag either of those.
You'll often get some calm and focus out of the practice, and that's welcome. The Stoics would just call it a side effect.
Myth 7: You have to be good at it before it counts
Plenty of people try one idea, lose their temper the next morning, and decide they're not the type.
Marcus seems to have had the same problem. In one note he tells himself: "Be not disgusted, nor discouraged, nor dissatisfied" when he doesn't manage to do everything by his principles (Meditations 5.9, Long's translation). Then he tells himself to come back and start again. He was the emperor, writing in a private notebook, and he still needed the reminder.
The Stoics had a word for the ideal wise person, the sage, and they thought such a person was extremely rare. Everyone else, Marcus included, counted as making progress, which is where a bad Tuesday leaves you too.
Where the critics have a point
Not every complaint is a myth. Stoicism really does ask you to treat a lot of things as outside your control, and done carelessly that can slide into detachment from problems that need your anger and your vote. Some readers find its talk of reason and nature too tidy for real grief. And many of the people who wrote it down were comfortable, powerful men, whatever they believed in principle.
Those are fair questions to bring to the texts. They're better questions than "do I have to stop feeling things?", which the texts answer clearly.
If you want to see for yourself
The quickest cure for any of these myths is a few pages of the actual books. Start with a short passage, read it slowly, and see whether it sounds like the cartoon. If you'd rather get one passage a day on your phone, that's what the Daily Stoic Wisdom app is for.
For a fuller first step, How to Start Your Stoic Journey lays out the basics, and the evening review is a ten-minute practice you can try tonight. There's more on our getting started page.
And the next time someone at dinner asks whether you've stopped feeling things, you can tell them Epictetus answered that one already. He had no wish to be a statue.